Translate to:

Kudos to Service Industry News

  • Rating: 0 after 1 vote

Instead of writing a “he said, she said” article about the plaster spotting controversy, Service Industry News (SIN) thought it would better serve the pool industry by conducting their own investigation to determine what information is true, and false. They started on that goal by analyzing the Cal Poly test pool studies. In their July 31, 2015 issue, SIN presented credible evidence (from the Cal Poly Phase 2 report) that the white spotting of the plaster test pools was not caused by aggressive water.

That conclusion directly refutes the NPC’s claim that the Cal Poly study proved that white spotting is caused by aggressive water. The SIN article pointed out that when the test pool’s plaster surfaces spotted or deteriorated in balanced water, the cause obviously has to be something else.

The article contains a thorough analysis and helps readers understand the Cal Poly report and what actually happened. This was a bold and courageous move by SIN. It was also a “right” thing to do, and they seem uniquely qualified since one of their editors (Marcelle Dibrell) has a PhD in chemistry, and is capable of scientific analysis.

A second article in that issue addresses the fact that the recently written NPC Plaster Standard lacked specifications, limits, and other valuable information on very important durability issues such as; water-to-cement ratios, calcium chloride content, mixing, water troweling, and other finishing techniques.

What is baffling is that the NPC is always touting that they promote and establish quality workmanship standards. But when the NPC received requests by industry members to acknowledge that there are limits on the amount of water and calcium chloride content, the NPC reply was that since they don’t know at what level to set the limits, they won’t set any limits at all. What was the purpose of spending more than a million dollars of industry money to study pool plaster issues at Cal Poly? As the other article illustrates, Cal Poly never was about studying plaster, it was about finger-pointing.

Former NPC Chairman Alan Smith is quoted as saying that the Plaster Standard should only contain “general” specifications, and that the Plaster Standard is a living document which can be added to later. But where are the general specifications? One could say that the NPC’s Plaster Standard contains no standards. In other words…..anything goes; at least in regards to workmanship.

And is it realistic to think that the NPC will allow changes in the future if the NPC is steadfastly refusing to establish specifications and limits up front - with all of the known cement science available? Why does this industry need to wait (5 more years!) for good standards to be adopted, and why should the plasterers get away with no standards now? One has to wonder if the NPC leaders realize that allowing inferior practices helps the poor quality plasterers, while hurting the good quality plasterers.

It appears that if the plaster spotting and discoloration controversy is ever going to end, PR rhetoric needs to be confronted and corrected with the truth so that the industry is aware. Kudos to Service Industry News for doing just that.

Views: 197


You need to be a member of Pool Genius Network to add comments!

Join Pool Genius Network

Comment by cindy mills on March 26, 2016 at 1:22pm

Thank you , Kim 

Comment by Richard A. Falk on August 9, 2015 at 11:39pm

Marcelle is great.  She's unbiased and just wants to get to the truth.  Service Industry News is very fortunate to have her as an editor.

Thank you again for taking a stand at disclosing the truth about plaster workmanship issues vs. water chemistry.

Sign in


 or Sign Up
By signing in, you agree to the amended Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
Forgotten your password?


Latest Activity

PGN Admin shared Kim Skinner's blog post on Facebook
15 hours ago
PGN Admin shared Kim Skinner's blog post on Facebook
15 hours ago
PGN Admin shared Kim Skinner's blog post on Facebook
15 hours ago
PGN Admin shared Que Hales's blog post on Facebook
15 hours ago
cbadrcdra76 is now a member of Pool Genius Network
Robert Fruland is now a member of Pool Genius Network
Mar 19
Que Hales posted a blog post

The Journal of the Swimming Pool and Spa Industry - New Volume 6 Now Online

The Journal of the Swimming Pool and Spa Industry is coming back! JSPSI, a peer-reviewed technical…See More
Mar 15
Aaron Darouse joined Rex Richard's group

Pool Careers

Post a pool industry job or resume! Admin., Marketing, Construction, Sales, Service, and RetailSee More
Mar 13
Profile IconNathan Bratt and Dante joined Pool Genius Network
Mar 12
Jacob Madden is now a member of Pool Genius Network
Mar 7
SHAWN SHEFFIELD is now a member of Pool Genius Network
Feb 27
Tomas wilson is now a member of Pool Genius Network
Feb 25
kevox712 is now a member of Pool Genius Network
Feb 18
Kim Skinner commented on Kim Skinner's blog post Plaster Finishes Should Last 20 Years
"Thanks Kevin, I like hearing that there are good plaster companies out there, and that they do good…"
Feb 18
Kevin Misley commented on Kim Skinner's blog post Plaster Finishes Should Last 20 Years
"Great info Kim. My plaster contractor will tent my pools if any threat of rain is present and also…"
Feb 17
Lyle Watson replied to Ben Jewell's discussion Open Pit DE Vacuum Filters
"I worked on several of these systems, many, many years ago. Are you still seeking…"
Feb 14

© 2019   Created by PGN Admin.   Powered by Pool Genius Network

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service


Live Video