Don't Solve the Problem ! Eliminate It!

I had some time to reflect recently. Here's why I had the time. Our kids are on the Mount Dora Swim Team and we're working to keep the city from closing the pool -- a tragedy for a pool dude like me -- so I volunteered for the fund raising golf event. My job was to watch the hole-in-one hole to verify any possible ace. I miscalculated the time I was going to be out there and quickly ran out of reading material so I SLOOOOOOOOWED DOOOOOOWN and READ slowly instead of the other thing I usually do.......I skim. Yes I am a skimmer man through and through which is where I found the one word that caught my eye.

It was "protection." And in context it was about a pool professional class in response to the new suction entrapment rules. The class was about "Suction Entrapment Protection......"

I remembered back to a giant banner I saw over a dozen years ago while I was still a corporate tool. Working at the 'happiest place on earth' -- Walt Disney World -- I saw this banner in our Team Disney building. It read:

Don't Solve Problems! Eliminate Them!

Another software team had just put in a new hotel reservation system and things were going pretty well (as I understood) but there was a still big 'war room' area with techs helping users with all kinds of problems. The mantra was obvious. Don't make a career out of these software problems. Eliminate them. We've got other things to do.

Today, as I look at the new ANSI 7 standards and all the options for protection against suction entrapment I am reminded of why many are pushing for only the protection against suction entrapment -- their career depends on them selling widgets and work-arounds and other things to help solve a problem that, if eliminated, would make them have to look for a new career.

While some advocate the need for suction in pools for hydraulics, a reasonable and knowledgeable pool builder would agree that at least 95% of all pool projects can be built while totally eliminating suction entrapment hazards. As busines people, surely there is a marketing hook here. And operationally, building without a drain is easier in most cases.

The only way to completely eliminate suction entrapment hazards is to eliminate the suction device completely.

As an industry, rather than continue with endless work-arounds we need to realize that we've got things to do - not necessarily 'better things to do' but more things to do in order to make our products safer and more efficient. Let's move forward and make careers of that!
E-mail me when people leave their comments –

You need to be a member of Pool Genius Network™ to add comments!

Join Pool Genius Network™

Comments

  • It is amazing to me that so many still believe that suction is needed for circulation, that direct suction outlets are required. Direct suction is the hazard, if we can eliminate the hazard the risk goes away. Thanks for the reminder. We need to help health departments understand the basic physics or flow to help them eliminate government mandates that public pools and spas must have direct suction.
  • Mark, you were in Disney's IT department? My brother in law is currently with Disney in that capacity. Small world (no pun intended).
  • WOW!!! I could not have said it better! I have seen this trend throughout PGN and I for one am so glad to see it. Going away from main drains are without a doubt the best thing that would happen to our industry in the public eye. It would show the public that we are very concerned with the well being of everyone that uses our products and we will go so far as to seek scientific data to back up our decisions. The one mindset that needs to leave our industry is the concept "we have done this forever, why change?". Change waits for no man (or woman), change will happen regardless of desire and for some that change will destroy them and for those that embrace it, they will go far.
This reply was deleted.